Buiding Church Leaders Home
Search By:
Advanced Search
Church RoleTopicFree Samples
Train LeadersAssess My ChurchConnect With LeadersRespond to CrisisMentor & DiscipleMultimediaStore
Home > Store > Case Study > Training Pack > Individual Handout
Case Study
The Slump of Second-Guessing

Making a decision doesn't always rest the case.
See "Working in Team Ministry" Training Pack
Store Code: CS02-E
Format(s): Microsoft Word
Type: Case Study
Price: $0.00

Add to Cart

Join Now!

Topics:Accountability, Church discipline, Church staff, Conflict, Decision making, Fellowship, Leadership, Volunteers
Filters:Church staff, Discipleship, Elder, Management, Pastor, Pastoral care, Shepherd
Purpose:Discipleship
References:Proverbs 6:1-5, Luke 11:29-32, Philippians 3:12-16
Date Added:July 31, 2007
share this pageshare this page



The Case
I believed our church should focus on building more leaders. So I met with members of the church board and said, "I need 10 men who'll meet with me for a year to study and pray. Those men will in turn disciple other men in the church. Our goal will be to disciple 50 men over the next five years."

The board approved the plan for Project Mustard Seed. But some board members began having second thoughts. "I think Project Mustard Seed is a great idea," one said. "But maybe we should have waited. Right now, we should really be spending more time visiting all the groups in the church and make them feel supported before starting something new."

Other members of the board began to agonize about whether they had made the right choice: Was it too late to back out? What would people who had been asked to participate in Mustard Seed think if the board pulled the program? Would the idea ever get off the ground?

What Would You Do?
• What can a board do when various people, including members of the board, begin to second-guess a decision it has made?
• When should we hold firm to what's been decided, despite criticism, and when should we change our decision?
• What are some things we can do to assure that once a decision has been made, there isn't a great deal of second-guessing?

What Happened
We all want to be like Jonah and have God audibly tell us, "Go to Nineveh." No mistake there! Though clear signs don't come as often as we want, we must not despair. Once in awhile, however, especially when we're attentive, God clarifies our uncertainty.

I was still stewing over the dilemma when I was vacationing in England. While touring the annual flower festival in a small Welsh village, I saw a display of the book I had just written titled Waiting. Alongside the stack of books was a flower pot with mustard seeds sprinkled over the top. The object lesson was a powerful confirmation of what God wanted done with Project Mustard Seed.

The board readily agreed to put the program on hold till a later time.

Leadership doesn't always equal certainty. We are quite willing and able to press ahead when we have no doubts. But we live as imperfect people in an imperfect world. True leadership sees the inevitable ambiguities of ministry yet has the spiritual sensitivity and resolve to advance through them.

Adapted from Who's in Charge? (Multnomah Books, 1993). Used with permission.

Discuss
1. According to Proverbs 6:1–5, what should we do with an unwise decision?

2. When is it better to wait for consensus on a decision rather than a simple majority before proceeding?

3. Suggest some ways we can deal with people's doubts or criticism of a board decision.

Average Rating: Not yet rated



Submit Your Rating and Review:

Choose star rating:

Name:
Comments: 1000 character limit 
 

Launching New Services and Sites
Is now the time?

Church Staff Evaluations
Evaluations are an essential way to help employees grow in their careers while keeping the church healthy.




Evaluating Group Discussions
How well do you practice these principles of small-group discussions?

Members

To view this content in full or to download the files, please login:

E-mail:
Password:
Non-Members

Please click here to find out more about starting a membership. As a member, you will be able to have access to all of the content on BuildingChurchLeaders.com.

Join now …