Average User Rating:
Displaying 15 of 65 comments
See all comments
While I very much applaud the intent of this quiz (love it, in fact), the questions themselves manifest a high level of bias against a kingdom (christo-centric) approach to the scriptures. Each question expects an answer along a 1 dimensional (conservative-liberal) continuum when in reality, many of these questions cannot be captured by a simple "low-med-high" approach. There is another "dimension" available which is being neglected.
Note question 16 especially: The belief that capital punishment is the god-given role of the state (but that the Christian should have no part in it) is completely orthogonal to how the question is written. Some of us can't answer it as written.
It was not hard for me to read too much into the questions. For example #1 The Bible is: What version of the bible are we talking about. I suppose as a conservative I would argue that there are really only a few reliable versions written in english. But some use the Living Bible or The Message as the Bible. In these cases I would say that those bibles are not the inspired words of God.
On enough issues, the options left out important possible answers. For example, on the Sabbath, the given options were between choosing a literal Saturday observance, or choosing some form of Sunday observance. What about Rom 14 telling us that it is ok for some to regard every day alike? I am a conservative (and tested so), but I choose not to observe any particular day as a Sabbath. Rather, should we not seek for every day in our lives to be holy for the Lord, sacrificing all that we are and all that we have in constant obedience to Him (Rom 12:1)? This quiz and the author's thoughts create a false dichotomy between holding onto things like OT stand on homosexuality, but letting go of things like the Sabbath. Is humanity's understanding of who God is and what what He asks of us not supposed to change as He reveals more of Himself and His plan unfolds throughout history?
Some things were not meant for all people for all times. I scored a 40.
Honestly--I think a label such as "conservative" vs "progressive" are cultural labels more than they are accurate assessments of varied Biblical exegesis. For instance, I was graded as conservative but my beliefs on the role of women in the church was considered "progressive". I don't base that belief on a cultural progression or the women's liberation movement but on the transcendent, inerrant scripture in Galatians that announced the equality of genders, races, and those under different socioeconomic status.
Be sure to click Submit when finished
1000 character limit
* Comments may be edited for tone and clarity.
RSS Feed | Help
Whatever your addiction, God's grace is the only hope for a way out.
The IRS scandal, Benghazi incidents, and the disappointment of dishonorable leadership.
Refusing to let beauty become a trap.
Cultivating ideas and thinking deeply can be spiritual acts of love.
Love compelled our church to get involved with the immigration issue.
Communicate about small groups in a clear, compelling way that draws people into groups.
Learn about God the Father, Jesus, and the Holy Spirit in this 3-session study.
Discover how to live life to the full.
Why this task can't continue to be an afterthought for leaders.
Is it legal to transfer the pastor's title to his home to our church?
How to succeed at a church renovation project, despite two painful realities of construction.
© 2013 Christianity Today
About Our Ministry |
Partner With Us |